Related posts: (1) China Environment: Auditor Emphasis of Matter raises more questions on potential accounting tunneling risk; (2) CFO reply: https://asianextractor.com/2015/02/10/potential-accounting-tunneling-fraud-at-china-environment/#comment-785 (3) Does Auditor Explanatory Language in Unqualified Audit Reports Indicate Increased Financial Misstatement Risk? “Emphasis of matter” language predicts restatements
Dear Mr Chiar,
Thank you for your reply addressing part of the corporate governance and accounting issues that were raised in Part 1 of the three-part article series that was based on the financial statements audited by Baker Tilly TFW LLP. We note that Baker Tilly did not disclose the name of its local auditor partners in the subcontract work for the wholly-owned subsidiaries Fujian Dongyuan 福建东源环保 and Anhui Dongyuan (Footnote 13) with the carrying value of RMB673.5m in FY14 (FY13: RMB698.7m), which form a very substantial part of the asset value of the group. We also note that Baker Tilly was recently fined in Dec 2014 by the U.S. SEC over audit failures tied to a mainland company suspected of fraud involving undisclosed related-party transactions; the audit failure was a result of subcontracting the audit work to a local partner. Continue reading