Posted by M Laavanya, Year 3 undergrad at the School of Accountancy, Singapore Management University
FRAUD IN THE BOARD
Sacked by Olympus for his stand against financial corruption, ex-CEO Michael Woodford describes what happened when he blew the whistle
This article was first published in the January 2013 International edition of Accounting and Business magazine.
With three decades working for a Japanese camera giant under your belt, you are rewarded for leading the growth of the European arm with promotion to company president – the first non-Japanese national ever to hold the post. The fact your new role starts on April Fool’s Day does not seem an omen.As you’re finding your feet, an article appears in an obscure Japanese magazine, Facta, alleging that your company had spent getting on for US$1bn on ‘minuscule’ businesses and writing off the costs in the subsequent year. The magazine also asks questions about the ‘bizarre acquisition’ of a British company at a large premium over its market capitalisation, with US$700m in unexplained advisory fees linked to the deal.
But your CEO brushes aside your questions, as do other senior colleagues. Suspicious, you start a paper trail, writing a formal letter to the company’s compliance officer.
As you turn up the heat, your new board colleagues get tense. A second article appears in Facta, mentioning ‘anti-social forces’, a euphemism for organised crime. The rest of the Japanese media studiously ignores the story, as do shareholders.
You start to fear having an ‘accident’. You suspect you are being followed. Any chance of a proper investigation could be buried with you.
Lacking hard evidence and aware of your fiduciary duties not to gratuitously damage the company but unable to ignore potential criminal activity, you start to copy your communications to the auditors – not just in Japan, but their colleagues in Asia, Europe and the US, as well as the audit firm’s global chairman.
This might all sound like the start of a fictional thriller but it is in fact the true story of Michael Woodford, the former CEO of Olympus, who in 2011 turned whistleblower on the company, which eventually admitted it had hidden losses of US$1.5bn in corrupt transactions and accounting scams.
He has now documented his story in a book, Exposure: Inside the Olympus Scandal. Readable and fast-paced, it details his growing suspicions that something was badly awry at Olympus, his battle to investigate, and the company’s attempt to appease him by briefly appointing him as CEO in September 2011 before unceremoniously dismissing him a fortnight later as both CEO and president. The book then covers his ultimately successful fight to expose what happened despite legal action from Olympus and the enormous travel and legal costs he had to shoulder.
Talking to Accounting and Business at his London flat, Woodford has both good and bad to say about the role of the various accountants and financial professionals involved in the events.
As he worked to build up a picture of the accounting manipulation and transactions that had taken place, he says he worked closely with three accountants in the UK.
NO WRIGGLE ROOM
‘They were very helpful. They helped me frame and structure the communications I started to write when I felt I needed to formalise and evidence what had gone on. They were very important in ensuring that we framed the questions in a way where they were very specific and left no wriggle room.’
Woodford has not named the three, other than to say they were Olympus employees. ‘They are very ethical and straightforward people and very committed to the company,’ he says.
But those with board responsibility come in for harsh criticism. In the book, Woodford recalls his sacking in a tense encounter with Hironobu Kawamata, the director and executive officer who was in effect CFO. Kawamata demanded Woodford hand over his phones and laptops, and ordered him to leave his apartment. ‘What shocked me is that he was so gratuitously hostile in the minutes immediately following my dismissal,’ says Woodford.
Tsuyoshi Kikukawa, the man Woodford had succeeded as president, remained chairman and assumed the new title of CEO. As well as serving as president for 10 years, Kikukawa had been head of the finance department. Kikukawa subsequently admitted filing false financial reports and, along with two other executives, at the time of going to press faces a prison term of up to 10 years.
Along with the rest of the Olympus board, Kawamata resigned in February 2012; he was not implicated in the criminal proceedings.
In Japan, says Woodford, it is not uncommon to find people in senior financial positions who haven’t had conventional accountancy training because managers are rotated around roles.
As his worries grew, Woodford sent a copy of his letters to the Olympus board to the Ernst & Young partners globally, which at the time enabled him to share his then unproved concerns with an external party without breaking his fiduciary duty to the company by going public. This transparency also provided some comfort at a time when he felt his safety was threatened.
But he adds: ‘I still find it hard to fathom how the auditors missed the fraudulent nature of these bizarre and sizeable transactions.’
EY took on the audit of Olympus in 2009, after the departure of KPMG. Michael Andrew, KPMG’s global chairman, spoke out in November 2011 about the Olympus scandal, saying: ‘We were displaced as a result of doing our job,’ and ‘It’s pretty evident to me there was very, very significant fraud and that a number of parties had been complicit.’
But Woodford comments in his book, having parted company with Olympus, why did KPMG not shout longer and louder? Second, if KPMG had been so concerned, how could it have signed off Olympus’s 2009 accounts without qualification?
Woodford also asks why the issue didn’t come up in its handover of the audit to EY. ‘I was surprised by how such extraordinary transactions did not raise alarm.’
EY declined to comment to Accounting and Business on its work
Since his official resignation from Olympus in November 2011, Woodford has given up on his attempt to take over the company with a new group of directors, and won a £10m settlement for unfair dismissal and discrimination. He has also been travelling the world speaking about the lessons to be learned from the scandal.
‘Many of your readers may not agree with me, but I do believe in the mandatory rotation of auditing firms,’ he says. ‘As human beings, if you know somebody else is going to come along and have another look, then you’d be much more cautious.’ He also has concerns about auditors selling consultancy services. ‘I know this creates loud and heated views, but the trouble is the world keeps seeing scandal after scandal.’
He points out that Japanese companies spend only around half as much on audits as do Western companies, and that some very large companies in Japan use very small audit firms – a ‘red flag’, adding ‘for capitalism to work, you need robust, vigorous external audits’.
Woodford also stresses the importance of independent mechanisms for whistleblowers to air their concerns while offering them comfort about their personal situation.
Although he is celebrated as a whistleblower, Woodford points out that he was not the true whistleblower who gave the story to Facta. His book describes a meeting late in the saga with this unnamed person over cans of Sapporo beer and Ritz crackers in a Tokyo flat. ‘He or she is the hero of the story. I had a foreign passport. I could get out.’
What shines out from the book is that the only effective mechanism for exposing Olympus was the media. Corporate governance, auditors, regulators and shareholders all failed.
Woodford lavishes praise on Facta but has harsh words for the rest of the Japanese media. Nervous about taking on a Nikkei company, they ignored the story until it had been broken in the Western media when Woodford, the day after his dismissal, called a Tokyo-based Financial Times journalist to give him the scoop of his life. The Financial Times, Wall Street Journal, The New York Times and Thomson Reuters, he says, should be credited for running with the story.
Woodford feels that judicial sanctions for white-collar crimes should be stiffer to discourage corporate fraud. ‘Executives should suffer custodial sentences, rather than just the companies paying fines. White-collar crime does have victims.’
It is clear that Woodford has a love and respect for Japan, and he dedicates his book to his ‘musketeers’: Koji Miyata, former head of Olympus’s medical business, and spokesman and translator Waku Miller, who supported him through the events.
But he says: ‘There is a very disturbing side to corporate life in Japan. That’s why I’m very sceptical about its prospects.’ His concerns range from its culture of deference and ‘yes men’, to the peculiarities of its ownership structures such as the cross-shareholding system in which large companies all own shares in each other. ‘There are probably other Olympuses out there in Japan,’ he says.
WHAT ABOUT THE REST OF THE WORLD?
He says: ‘We’re still not in a position where we should feel comfortable or complacent.’
Woodford says he has not been short of job offers, but has preferred to spend time talking and writing about his experiences and the issues that have arisen from them.
And, of course, he’s been writing the book, which he says nearly killed him. ‘It’s not sanitised and I’m very explicit. I refer to lots of names and people. Three sets of lawyers reviewed the book. I think it will appeal to a lot of people in business, and the finance sector in particular – where you wear a suit and go to work, send emails, go to meetings, work on Excel spreadsheets, and suddenly you find yourself in this John Grisham-like novel.
Michael Woodford MBE grew up in Liverpool and joined Olympus as a salesman, rising through the ranks to run its UK, European and global operations. In April 2011 he was appointed president and CEO of Olympus Corporation, the first Western salaryman to rise through the ranks to the top of a Japanese giant. As a result of the events described in Exposure he was named Businessman of the Year 2011 by The Sunday Times, The Independent and The Sun and won The Financial Times Mittal Arcelor Award for Boldness in Business.
Chris Quick, editor